Blog 4

 In the story “Their Eyes Were Watching God,” the story shows the life of Janie Crawford. Jane is an African-American woman living in the early 20th century. The story shows Janie’s quest for self-discovery and love. Her  journey begins with her first marriage to an older man named Logan Killicks. However, the relationship lacks passion and fulfillment, prompting Janie to leave Logan and pursue a more meaningful connection. She then meets Joe Starks, a charismatic and ambitious man, and they move to Eatonville, Florida. Joe becomes the town’s mayor, but as time passes, Janie realizes that their marriage is stifling her spirit.

For some critics, it could be troubling that Pheoby implicitly ends up narrating Janie’s story in “Their Eyes Were Watching God” due to the idea of self-determination, as we discussed last week with Passing. Also it raises questions about the reliability and objectivity of the narrative. Furthermore, Pheoby’s status as a character within the story might introduce biases or limitations to the storytelling, which could be seen as problematic.

Additionally, critics could argue that Pheoby’s narration could potentially weaken the emotional impact of the narrative. Storytelling is a very personal way of writing and it is usual drawn from life experiences. Pheoby narration could create a sense of detachment from the protagonist’s journey which might distance the readers from Janie’s personal experiences. from the protagonist’s journey.When Jania shared her story with Pheoby, it was in confidence because she treated her well and never judged her. 

“So she sat on the porch and watched the moon rise. Soon its amber fluid was drenching the earth, and quenching the thirst of the day.”This quote showcases Janie’s agency and her ability to reflect on her own experiences. Her observation of the moonrise and its symbolic significance highlights her individual voice and perspective.

“Experience is the biggest teacher of all, and I been with God a long time.” This quote suggests that Pheoby’s role as a narrator can be seen as a means to learn from Janie’s experiences. While Pheoby acts as a conduit for Janie’s story, her presence does not necessarily undermine Janie’s voice and self-determination. 

 “Ah knowed you wouldn’t miss it. Airline pilots ain’t no ways different.”This quote, spoken by Pheoby to Janie, implies a certain belittlement of Janie’s experiences and her desire for autonomy. It undermines Janie’s voice and agency by reducing her journey to a common occurrence and suggesting that her desires are nothing out of the ordinary.

Focusing on the relationship between Pheoby’s role as a narrator and Janie’s voice and self-determination provides an interesting lens through which to analyze the novel. It opens up discussions around authorial intent, narrative structure, and the importance of individual perspectives.

On the other hand, some critics might not find this narratorial layer troubling. They might argue that Pheoby’s narration serves to enhance the authenticity and richness of the story. By allowing Pheoby to tell Janie’s story, it provides a more rounded perspective and gives voice to the community that surrounds Janie. This can provide a more holistic understanding of the characters and their environment.

I believe that Pheoby’s implicit narration adds depth to the story. Her narration may introduce potential biases or limitations, it also allows for a broader exploration of themes and a more nuanced portrayal of the community dynamics. I think that as long as readers are critical and aware of the additional narratorial layer, it can be seen as a deliberate narrative choice that contributes to the overall narrative structure and thematic development.

How does Janie’s journey of self-discovery unfold throughout the novel? What did all of Janie’s relationships teach her? How does Janie challenge traditional gender roles and expectations in the novel? How did Janie’s relationships with her three husbands differ, and what do they reveal about her character? What is the role of nature and its symbolism in the story?